Trying to get in shape, but torn between the elliptical and the treadmill? You’re not alone. With so many fitness machines out there, deciding which one best suits your goals can be overwhelming.
Choosing the right equipment matters—not only for burning calories, but also for comfort, joint health, and lasting motivation.
In this article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of both machines, give practical tips, and help you discover which is the better fit for your workout needs.
Related Video
Elliptical Machine vs. Treadmill: Which Is Better for You?
When it comes to cardio equipment, the elliptical machine and the treadmill are two of the most popular choices at the gym or for home workouts. But a question many people ask is: which one is better? While both machines offer excellent cardiovascular benefits, the best option really depends on your fitness goals, physical condition, and personal preferences.
Let’s break down the pros, cons, and practical factors so you can make an informed—and confident—decision.
Understanding the Basics
Before diving into comparisons, let’s take a quick look at each machine:
What Is an Elliptical Machine?
- Provides a smooth, gliding motion similar to walking or running.
- Typically includes arm handles, letting you work out your upper and lower body at the same time.
- Low-impact, meaning it’s gentle on your joints.
What Is a Treadmill?
- Lets you walk, jog, or run in place on a moving belt.
- Many treadmills offer incline settings, simulating uphill walking or running.
- Generally, higher impact—especially at faster speeds or higher inclines.
Key Differences: Elliptical vs. Treadmill
Let’s look at some of the ways these two machines differ, and what that means for your workout.
1. Impact on Joints
- Elliptical: Low-impact. The pedals support your feet, reducing stress on your knees, hips, and ankles. Great for people with joint pain or recovering from an injury.
- Treadmill: Higher impact. Especially at higher speeds or when running, the repeated pounding can stress your joints over time.
2. Calorie Burn
- Both machines can burn a significant number of calories, depending on intensity.
- Treadmill: Running usually burns more calories in the same amount of time compared to using an elliptical.
- Elliptical: Burns slightly fewer calories on average than running. However, using the arm handles to pump your upper body can increase calorie burn.
3. Muscle Groups Targeted
- Elliptical: Offers a full-body workout. You’ll engage your legs, core, and—when using the arm handles—your chest, back, and arms.
- Treadmill: Focuses primarily on the lower body: quads, hamstrings, calves, and glutes. Incline walking can help target different leg muscles.
4. Versatility and Customization
- Elliptical: Allows for forward and backward motion, changing which muscles are emphasized. Resistance levels can be adjusted for increased intensity.
- Treadmill: Offers adjustable speeds and inclines, letting you mimic walking, jogging, running, or hiking.
5. Exercise Variety
- Elliptical: Great for interval training and steady-state cardio. Reverse pedaling adds variation.
- Treadmill: Excellent for HIIT (high-intensity interval training), sprints, and endurance runs.
6. Accessibility
- Elliptical: May feel awkward for beginners, but easy on the body.
- Treadmill: Walking on a treadmill feels natural; running can be more challenging.
The Benefits of Each Machine
Benefits of Elliptical Machines
- Low-Impact Cardio: Protects joints and reduces injury risk.
- Full-Body Workout: Engages both upper and lower body.
- Great for Rehabilitation: Ideal for people recovering from lower body injuries.
- Easy to Modify Intensity: Adjustable resistance and stride direction.
- Safer for Balance Issues: Your feet remain planted on the pedals.
Benefits of Treadmills
- Natural Movement: Walking and running are familiar to most people.
- Higher Calorie Burn Potential: Especially when running or using incline.
- Customizable Workouts: Speed, incline, and timing are easily adjustable.
- Improves Bone Density: The impact from running helps keep bones strong.
- Great for Building Endurance: Lets you train for walks, hikes, or running events.
Challenges and Considerations
Challenges of Using the Elliptical
- Lower Calorie Burn (Typically): Might not burn as many calories as high-intensity treadmill workouts.
- Less Strength Requirement: Doesn’t load bones or muscles as heavily as running does.
- Learning Curve: Takes a bit to get used to the motion.
Challenges of Using the Treadmill
- High Impact: Can be tough on knees, ankles, and back.
- Risk of Injury: Especially at high speeds or inclines if you’re not careful.
- Monotony: Some may find treadmill walking or running boring.
How to Decide: Which Machine Is Right for You?
Everyone’s situation is unique. Here’s how you can figure out which machine best fits your circumstances.
1. Set Your Fitness Goals
Ask yourself:
– Are you training for a running event?
– Is weight loss your primary aim?
– Are you focused on joint health and mobility?
– Do you want a full-body workout?
2. Consider Any Health Issues
- If you have arthritis, joint pain, or are recovering from injury, the elliptical is likely a safer bet.
- If you have healthy joints and want to build running endurance or bone strength, the treadmill may be beneficial.
3. Think About Motivation and Enjoyment
- Which machine do you enjoy more? Consistency matters most, so pick the one you’ll be excited to use.
4. Try Both if Possible
- Most gyms have both machines, so test them out and see which one feels better for your body and fitness level.
Practical Tips for Using an Elliptical or Treadmill
Elliptical Best Practices
- Keep your posture upright; don’t lean too far forward or backward.
- Use the handles to work your upper body, but don’t grip too tightly.
- Change direction occasionally (forward and backward) to engage different muscles.
- Mix up resistance and speed for interval training benefits.
- Adjust the stride length for comfort.
Treadmill Best Practices
- Start slow—especially if you haven’t run in a while.
- Use the incline feature to add variety and challenge different muscles.
- Focus on maintaining good running or walking form: shoulders relaxed, core engaged.
- Avoid holding onto the handrails unless necessary for balance.
- Incorporate interval sessions—alternate periods of high intensity with recovery.
Safety Guidelines
- Always warm up before starting, regardless of the machine.
- Wear proper athletic shoes with good support.
- Stay hydrated.
- If you feel pain (other than typical muscle fatigue), stop and consult a healthcare professional.
Conclusion: So, Which Cardio Machine Is Better?
There isn’t one “better” machine for everyone. The elliptical and treadmill both offer excellent ways to improve your cardio fitness, burn calories, and support your overall health.
- If joint health, injury prevention, or a full-body workout is your priority, the elliptical may come out ahead.
- If maximum calorie burn, natural movement, or building running endurance are your main goals, the treadmill is likely your winner.
Ultimately, the best cardio machine is the one you’ll use consistently and enjoy. Listen to your body, set clear goals, and don’t be afraid to switch things up to keep your workouts exciting!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Which machine is better for weight loss: treadmill or elliptical?
Both can be effective for weight loss if you maintain a calorie deficit. Generally, running or incline walking on a treadmill burns more calories per minute than an elliptical session. However, using the elliptical with high intensity and adding arm movement can help you burn just as many calories.
2. Are ellipticals actually easier on the joints compared to treadmills?
Yes. Ellipticals offer low-impact exercise because your feet never leave the pedals, which greatly reduces stress on knees and hips. Treadmills can be harder on your joints, especially if you’re running or using higher inclines.
3. Does either machine build more muscle?
Both primarily offer cardiovascular benefits, but treadmills (especially at higher inclines) activate and strengthen the muscles in your legs more intensely. The elliptical targets both your upper and lower body but doesn’t provide as much resistance as strength training.
4. Is the treadmill better for training for outdoor running?
Absolutely! Since the treadmill closely mimics walking or running outdoors, it’s a better option for those training for a race or who want to improve their outdoor running performance.
5. What if I have balance issues?
The elliptical is often safer for those with balance challenges because your feet stay firmly planted on the pedals, and most machines have sturdy handles. On the treadmill, walking at a slow pace with handrail support may also be safe, but running can increase fall risk.
Remember, both machines can help you reach your fitness goals. The key is to pick the equipment that aligns with your needs, keeps you injury-free, and motivates you to stick with your workout routine!